4 Lessons Science And Religion Both Taught Me

I remember once being in a philosophy class.  It was a winter “enrichment” course for 7th graders.  It was our last day.  Everyone was telling the class what they gained out of it.

Some people said it “expanded their minds”.  Some said it changed the way they looked at things.

When it was my turn, I said, “Now I’m more open to the idea of G-d.”

Everyone around me at the time kind of looked shocked.  Some of them laughed and said, “Really?”

I nodded.

They all started exclaiming that the class made them believe in G-d a lot less.  Especially all the philosophy of science stuff.  How could you learn all that, expand your mind so much, and still believe in something as limited as G-d?

I couldn’t explain it at the time, but I think what had happened was that by realizing how infinite, how full of possibility the universe really was, the more I started to become open to the idea that there might be a god who runs things.

Sometimes I feel like I’m still in that seventh grade philosophy class.  The more I learn about science, and the more I learn about religion, the more I feel like the two so beautifully complement each other.  The more people debate and argue, the more I see the commonality between the two.

There are so many lessons that both science and religion can teach us that I thought I would take this time to enumerate just a few.  Lessons that have so hit me, so powerfully moved me, no matter what source I learned it from, that I can’t see how anyone could see a conflict between science and religion.

1. I’m Not In Control

Learning about science taught me just how little control I have over the universe.  I learned that things are more based on probability than anything, that the vastness of everything happening around me means that at any moment, anything could happen.

It’s kind of mind-boggling to accept that reality.  To know how, really, you’re just taking every step with a sort of weird trust.  A trust that a car won’t plow into you.  Or maybe it will.  But all you can do is move on.

Believing in G-d is so similar, on an emotional level, that it’s almost like we’ve used different words to describe a similar idea.  Accepting that G-d is completely in control of every moment immediately implies that we aren’t in control of anything.  Perhaps science uses the word probability for the same phenomenon.  Religion just implies that the randomness, the lack of our control, is really just a sign of a grander plan.

But either way, the point is that I have no control.  When I pray, even when I’m praying for something good to happen, or for a person to not be sick any longer, I am not in any means controlling the universe.  Instead, I’m acknowledging that I have absolutely zero control.  I am beseeching because I know how small I am.  I know that I am just a passenger on the plane, and the only way I’ll be able to go where I want to go is to speak to the pilot.

2. I’m Insanely Small

The more science learns, the more it seems to realize just how small we really are.  Back in the day, we used to think we were just a planet with a sun and a moon.  Now we know we are a planet among nine in a solar system, among a crazy amount of other solar systems within one of billions of galaxies, within a universe more vast than we can imagine.

If that’s not a spiritual realization, I don’t know what is.

The funny thing is that spiritual folks have been trying since the dawn of humanity to realize just how small they are.  How they’re essentially nothing in comparison to what’s really real: ie G-d.

Religious people have known forever how important it is to embrace that fact.  To accept our tininess, to remain humble in the face of everything the universe is and everything that’s beyond it.  So many of us spend our lives acting like we’re the main characters in a movie that we forget our whole reason for living is to connect to that infinitude and bring it out in the world by living a life with a mission, not just a life of self-gratification.

The surprising thing to me is that people seem to think that science somehow teaches the opposite.  That our smallness is an implication that nothing matters and we should just give up and live a life devoted to ourselves.

How short-sighted!  How sad!  And what a sad twisting of the reality of the world.  To remember that our smallness is simply a reminder to live our lives in a state of giving is the greatest lesson both science and religion can teach us.

3. I’m A Miracle

Okay, so I’m small.  Fine.

But no matter what you believe, there’s no question whatsoever that our just existing is the most special thing we could ever imagine.

Let’s take science.  If you believe that we originated in some sludge, and then that sludge turned into a single celled organism and that turned into something and that something turned into something and eventually, after billions of years, out came you… um, how insanely amazing is that?  What are the chances of that?  I’m sure someone calculated that at some point, but I’m too lazy to Google it.  Anyway, it’s insanely, completely small.

And sure, many will argue, if you take billions of years and hundreds of billions of galaxies, eventually you’ll make a human.

Fine.  But who cares.  The point is that it happened to you.  That here you are, out of all those billions of galaxies and billions of years and all that business.  Here you are.  Take a moment and soak that in.  You are a miracle.

And if you’re an insane religious nutball like me and you believe that G-d made the world in six days (however you interpret that, whether it be six days that were really billions of years or six days that were actually six days), you simply can’t help but be blown away.  I mean, that something as immense as G-d, something so beyond reality and so real, the only thing that’s real, could take a moment out of his busy day and make me, and care about me.

Judaism teaches that we need to simultaneously realize that we are but like sand on a beach, but also that G-d made the entire universe just for us.  Just for you.  Just for me.  For each of us.

I’m a miracle.  And so are you.

4. Nothing Makes Sense

This is one I think that both the fanatics of science and the fanatics of religion hate accepting.  In fact, you could say they twist the reality of both science and religion to make themselves believe they have some measure of true understanding of the way the world works.

What’s funny is that it seems the more you study about science, the more you realize how little you know.  Our brains are limited.  There’s no way we can fully comprehend how things can be in two places at once, how things that look solid to our eyes are really just a bunch of atoms and those atoms are really just energy.

The same is true, I’ve found, of religion.  The funny thing about studying Hasidus, a mystical Jewish tradition, is that the answer for why G-d created the world is simply because, “He wanted to.”

Yep, that’s it.  And sure, there are super deep ideas of what “want” means.  But, look, the point is that we’ll never grasp it.  That the creation of the universe from G-d’s perspective is something that makes absolutely zero sense.

The fanatics on both sides hate hearing this point.  They want to believe that science or religion gives us access to true knowledge!  That the more we learn, the more we know!  That when someone argues with us because of their point of view that gosh darnit, they’re so wrong because they don’t have access to our amazing sources of knowledge.

Fanatics love thinking they know things.

But a true believer of religion knows that he knows, essentially, nothing.  And anyone that accepts that the reality of science is a constant growth in knowledge that changes, evolves, over time, realizes how little they really know.

And so, fine, maybe we don’t agree on all the details, and maybe we’re worlds apart (billions of galaxies?), on some of our beliefs.  But that’s so external, it’s almost laughable that anyone gives a crap.

Spirituality, truth, reality, these are all things that the external forces of the study of science and the idea of religion can only put clumsy words around.  That our minds can only pretend to grasp.

But they are there, and whatever method we use to access them doesn’t change that fact.  Truth is something we tap into, not something we can hold and examine.

If only everyone accepted that, maybe there would be less arguments between people who claim to believe in different things.






7 responses to “4 Lessons Science And Religion Both Taught Me”

  1. Rebecca White Avatar
    Rebecca White

    Love this!

  2. s1234s Avatar

    Elad, can you write a book please? =)

    I’m going through such a difficult phase at the moment where I feel cut off from my community, myself, but most of all, my Creator.

    School religious education classes were always an excuse for me to become irrational and arrogant in my agnostic beliefs.

    I remember the moment when I realised I wasn’t in control…how terrifying and liberating it felt.

    I went through such a deep intellectual revolution when I accepted the reality of a Creator. I think I got so caught up in the little nothings of life that I forgot the beauty of just being. I feel like you wrote this for me. Thank you. Thank you so much.

    1. Elad Nehorai Avatar

      Haha, I actually AM working on a book. A memoir. About 95 pages in! I’ll keep you updated.

      I’m so sorry to hear you’re having a difficult time. The truth is that I think that stage is fairly normal for religious folks (although I don’t know the details so I can’t tell for sure). I think it’s especially difficult for people like us that became religious later because, unlike religious folk who are used to the up and down rhythms of spiritual connection, we’ve mistakenly assumed that the high we felt at the beginning will always be there.

      But again, I have no real idea what you’re going though. Either way, I hope you feel connected again soon 🙂

      And btw, I totally identify with the concept of “irrational and arrogant” agnostic beliefs. I remember judging and looking down on some of my religious Christian friends, and how over about a year spent in close proximity with them, realizing how much more sensitive and real they were than me. That was pretty eye-opening.

      I also have a VERY big difficulty with letting go of control. I am constantly realizing I’m actually using my faith to convince myself that I have a measure of control. Which is hard. Something I’m always working on. But, in the end, I agree, the more we accept that reality, and just BE, the happier and more fulfilled we get.

      1. s1234s Avatar

        Yay! I can’t wait to read it!
        Will I be able to order from the UK?

        Thank you for such a genuine reply. I’m going to try to keep reflecting and connect to the universe on a realer level…and just BE =)

        I have to stop expecting change to fall on top of me and start climbing up to it every day, regardless of what goes on around me.


    2. Wan Abi Sufi Avatar
      Wan Abi Sufi

      Your wriing is focussed toward jews, but you talk about such human qualities.

      Yes, write a book.

  3. Nur Fatin Nordin Avatar
    Nur Fatin Nordin

    I love your article. Thank you. It’s dawned upon me that many of us often chase after our desires and forget our sole purpose of living. I’ve seen a friend of mine being made fun of because he was supposedly more religious and it’s a fact that the people who were mocking him can’t accept.

    I found it quite odd how I felt hurt seeing them do that to him, but he was not the least bit affected. It was then that I realised, nothing else matters when your focus is shifted to Him and only Him. It was really an eye-opener for me. 🙂

  4. daniel Avatar

    In the end you are claiming that all knowledge is relative, religious and empirical, and that’s why you accept the existance of the concept of a “God”, let me remind you created by humans, therefore innacurate to any extend. If you truly get this deep in your reasoning, then your realisation, in all honesty, is that all concepts, all “truths”, are a lie, a mere ilusion to us all, the simple idea of knowing, in a religious or empirical way, is laughable and you are just fooling yourself the same way as everybody else. Just my opinion :D, anyway, don’t worry about that stuff so much, it’s dangerous if you get into extremes in religious and dogmatic perspectives. Experience.
    Long live and prosper jeje

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *